Discover what you are naturally good at

Insights Discovery vs DISC Personality Tests: All Pros & Cons

Discovering and leveraging your innate strengths is crucial for personal growth, career development, and achieving your goals. While assessments like Insights Discovery and DISC provide valuable insights into your personality traits, the HIGH5 strengths test takes a unique approach by identifying your top five strengths from a comprehensive list of research-backed talent themes.

Understanding your strengths empowers you to capitalize on your natural abilities, unleash your potential, and navigate life’s challenges more effectively. The HIGH5 assessment not only reveals your unique strengths but also provides personalized strategies to maximize their application in various aspects of your life, from relationships and communication to goal-setting and decision-making.

Insights Discovery vs DISC Personality Tests All Pros & Cons

In this article, we’ll compare the Insights Discovery and DISC personality tests, exploring their similarities and differences. However, we’ll also highlight how the HIGH5 strengths assessment complements these tests by offering a strengths-based perspective that can amplify your personal and professional growth.

By gaining insights into your core talents and learning how to leverage them intentionally, you can experience numerous benefits, including enhanced self-awareness, improved performance, increased motivation, and a greater sense of fulfillment. Unlock your true potential and achieve remarkable outcomes by embarking on a journey of self-discovery with the HIGH5 strengths assessment.

Systems Compared: The 4 Quadrants vs The 4 Types

When looking at the DISC test and the Insights Discovery assessment, one of their starkest differences are in the way the systems are structured. It is crucial to recognize these differences to accurately understand what your results mean.

The Insights Discovery assessment is based on a system of 4 quadrants. The Insights Discovery test is based on categorizing individuals in a 4 quadrant system. These 4 quadrants have numerous personality traits associated with them.

The quadrants range from being reserved for being sociable on the y-axis, and from task to propel-oriented on the x-axis.

The other assessment, the DISC test, categorizes you into 4 types. In this way, it is a bit less specific. Each of the letters in the DISC acronym stands for a different type: D for dominance, I for Influence, S for steadiness, and C for conscientiousness.

Most people have numerous of these traits making up their personality. But it is also true that most are dominant in one or two of them.

Compared with HIGH5

The HIGH5 test differs from the DISC and Insight Discovery assessments in one major way: the HIGH5 is a strength test, but the other two are more so personality tests.

The HIGH5 test categorizes individuals into far more than just 4 different groups. There is a wide variety of different personality characteristics that the HIGH5 test could assign to you.

In addition, the DISC and the Insight Discovery tests do not give you a ranking of your traits. However, the HIGH5 test will provide you with not just one match and one characteristic that is a major part of your personality, but rather 5 unique matches.

Categories and Structure: 4 Dimensions vs 4 Colors

To understand your strengths, you should consider taking either the DISC assessment or the Insight Discovery system. However, these tests are also quite different.

If you want to get the most out of either of these assessments, consider learning more about these differences. This will allow you to also know which test is the best for you.

One of these key differences comes in the form of the tests’ structure and categories. With the Insight Discovery test, you will be assigned results and categorized into one of 4 groups.

These groups are associated with 4 colors, each of which stands for different characteristics, specifically the way you lead.

The colors include cool blue (cautious), red (competitive), yellow (sociable), and Earth green (caring). There are other traits associated with each of these colors, too. Therefore, there are numerous dimensions associated with each of the colors.

The DISC test also categorizes you into one of 4 groups. Additionally, this test also includes colors when creating assignments.

However, the DISC assessment is a bit more straightforward. With each color, there are fewer different traits tied to it. Instead, the DISC results look a bit like a compass.

Your results are categorized depending on whether you are outgoing vs reserved and whether you are task-oriented or people-oriented, as well as your combination of these two traits.

Compared to HIGH5

The HIGH5 test is not quite a personality assessment. Instead, HIGH5 gives you a great overview of your strengths profile. Thus, your weaknesses will not be discussed. This is similar to the way both DISC and the Insights Discovery system work (no emphasis on your weaknesses).

However, the HIGH5 test categorizes your results differently from the prior mentioned assessments. There are no color categories with HIGH5. Instead, you will be given a strengths character (like an Empathizer is you are gentle, caring, nurturing, etc.).

Along with these strengths characters come numerous strengths. This is similar to the way the DISC and Insight Discovery systems assign numerous traits to colors. You will not just be given one strength character match, though.

Instead, you will be given 5, ranked from best to worst match. Thus, you will be given a more complete picture of your strengths profile by taking the HIGH5.

Looking for a comprehensive strengths test?
People are switching from the DISC and Insights Discovery assessments to the HIGH5 strengths test. Join over 3 million people in discovering what you are naturally great at.

What Do Results Tell You? Personal Traits vs Personal Development

Another one of the most important differences between the DISC and the Insights Discovery assessment is what the results show you. Regardless of which test you take, you will get a wide variety of benefits from understanding the results.

The Insights Discovery test results will present you with some personal traits, while the DISC test will give you various approaches toward self-development.

The Insight Discovery test will categorize you into numerous quadrants. Each of these is associated with a color, and that color contains a list of several personality traits associated with it.

If you want a straightforward analysis, stating simply what your top personality traits are, then you should consider taking the Insights Discovery test.

On the other hand, if you are looking for a more in-depth analysis of your personal development, the DISC test may be more useful to you. This test is focused on analyzing your communication and leadership style.

By understanding these results you can optimize your leadership methods and achieve more in your career. So, the assessment is highly useful for self-improvement or self-development goals.

Compared to HIGH5

The HIGH5 test covers a wide variety of your strengths. While the DISC test mostly focuses on your leadership and communication style, the HIGH5 will also give you insights into your decision-making, stress management, empathy, and many other skills.

Therefore, the HIGH5 test is far more comprehensive in giving a full view of your strengths profile. The Discovery Insights test gives you more specific details about only certain parts of your strengths profile.

Additionally, the HIGH5 is also highly useful in assisting you with your personal development journey. There are great pieces of information that you can acquire from the DISC test on your communication and leadership.

You can also find key information on these skills from the HIGH5 test. But, if the HIGH5 test finds you are not a great communicator or leader, these strengths will not be displayed. Rather, you will find different skills shown in your report.

What Do Tests Highlight? Characteristics vs Relationships

One of the most important crucial factors of any personality test is what these assessments choose to highlight. This could be the deciding factor in helping you choose which test is right for you.

If someone takes the Insights Discovery test, they will learn more about their character and overall personality traits. The test is more in-depth and covers numerous elements of your personality.

When you finish this test, you will be assigned a quadrant and color. From then, you can see the numerous characteristics that are associated with your results.

If you would take the DISC test, then you will see your relationship skills and the way you approach relationship building. As previously mentioned, the assessment is focused on leadership and communication.

These two skills are crucial in developing strong relationships. If you know how to communicate, and have great communication skills, you can build trust as well as long-lasting positive relationships. Knowledge of your relationship-building style is especially crucial for your personal life, not just your career.

Compared to HIGH5

The HIGH5 test is focused on testing one important factor of your personality: your strengths. This is somewhat different from both of the assessments discussed above, as they are either focused on general personality characteristics or on leadership plus communication.

The HIGH5 test will likely highlight some aspects of your leadership and communication, too, as the DISC test does.

The difference between the two systems is that the HIGH5 test provides you with far more information than just your leading and communication methods, though. You will also gain insights on your emotional strengths, for example.

Is Discovery Insights the Same as DiSC?

Many individuals confuse the DISC test with the Discovery Insights assessment. These tests are certainly very similar. They both have 4 main categories for their results, both center around testing your personality, and the questions are similar.

However, these tests are not exactly the same. Knowing the difference between the two of them is crucial in knowing which is right for you.

The theory behind the Insights Discovery test is based on the research of psychologist Carl Jung. He believed that individuals could be categorized into 4 main groups based on their goal orientation, communication, leadership, and other factors.

Each of these four categories is associated with a color: red for achievement, yellow for sociability, Earth green for caringness, and blue for meticulousness. Most people’s personality is a combination of these factors, but one of them is still likely dominant.

The DISC test covers your levels of 4 distinct traits: D for dominance, I for influence, S for submission or steadiness, and C for conscientiousness.

William Marston is the psychologist behind this test. Similarly to the Insights Discovery test, most people are a combination of these 4 factors, but one likely stands out.

One of the key differences between these assessments is who can administer them. You can only take the Insights Discovery test officially through one company, and they are the only group managing the test questions.

On the other hand, there are numerous different companies offering DISC tests. There is some variety in the test questions you are asked with the DISC test depending on which version you take. There is no standard single version of DISC like there is of the Insights Discovery assessment.

Looking for a comprehensive strengths test?
People are switching from the DISC and Insights Discovery assessments to the HIGH5 strengths test. Join over 3 million people in discovering what you are naturally great at.

Is Insights Discovery Accurate?

After reading the above descriptions of the Insights Discovery test, you may be interested in taking it. However, and important question arises: just how accurate is the Insights Discovery test, and personality tests like it? The reality is that many researchers and laymen disagree on this issue.

For some, these tests give very valuable and necessary feedback on their personality. Others believe it is pseudoscience and not useful.

The Insights Discovery test has scientific backing in its origin. It was first developed by Carl Jung’s research, along with his mentee Dr. Jolande Jacobi. He divided individuals into 4 groups based on their feeling vs thinking preference as well as their extroversion vs introversion preference.

These divisions led to the development of the color-coded quadrant system used in the Insights Discovery test today. The test is quite comprehensive and offers relatively non-biased insights on your top personality traits. Therefore, many individuals consider it to be accurate and helpful.

What are the 4 DiSC Personality Types?

The DUSC personality test categorizes test takers into one of 4 groups. To understand your result, you need to be aware of what each of these groups stands for and means.

The first of them is D for dominance. These individuals think in the long term and do not stress over details. They are outspoken and confident, sometimes a bit arrogant, and have high standards for themselves as well as others.

The I stands for influence. Influencers believe they can achieve the most by having others support their cause. Thus, they are great at persuading. Influencers are naturally trusting, have lots of energy, and tend to speak openly as well as optimistically.

The S stands for steadiness. These individuals like to work with others and try to avoid stressful situations. They are dependable and calm. Stead people want to take time to make the best decisions; they dislike being rushed. Such individuals are known for their loyalty and enjoy a consistent routine.

The C stands for conscientiousness. Conscientious people are highly meticulous and like to be precise. When they learn and focus on something, they want to become experts. Conscientious individuals are detail-oriented, prefer independent work, and strongly dislike being wrong.

What is the Purpose of Insights Discovery?

The Insights Discovery test offers a wide array of benefits for those who take the time to answer its questions. These benefits apply to nearly all aspects of an individual’s life, whether it be their personal relationships or achieving their career goals.

One of the most important benefits associated with this assessment is the boost of knowledge it gives someone about their personality.

Being aware of your personality helps you make logical career decisions and encourages you to pursue self-improvement. It can motivate you to overcome challenges and help you see the positive side of your personality as well.

In addition to this, the Insights Discovery test can help you collaborate with others. When you know the personality profiles of those around you, you can work with those who have the greatest match to your communication as well as leadership methods. Thus, the test can boost your cooperation and productivity.

Finally, another bonus of the Insights Discovery test is that it helps the team establish a United understanding of one another. When everyone recognizes each other’s strengths and weaknesses in their personality, they are more inclined to work well and stay focused.

Final words

In summary, there are many benefits that come with taking either the DISC test or the Insights Discovery test. These assessments can both give you extremely valuable, feedback on your personality.

If you want to know more about your personality characteristics, then the Insights Discovery test is likely right for you. If you want more straightforward input centered around your communication and leading abilities, then the DISC test is likely a better fit for your goals.

Both of these assessments categorize you into 4 groups depending on how you answer their questions. In fact, the types of questions they ask are also quite similar. But, there are many different versions of the DISC test, each with a different array of questions. The Insights Discovery test only has one official version.

Regardless of which test you think is right for you, learning about your personality offers many crucial benefits. It can help you both in your social life and with your career development. By learning about your key personality traits, you will become more self-aware and more confident.

Table of Contents
Blog Feedback
Not at all Likely Extremely Likely
Join +3 million people from leading companies in discovering what they are naturally great at