Those comparing the Enneagram system vs the Myers-Briggs system often find it challenging to choose between them. On the one hand, the Enneagram system focuses more on motivations and life purpose. In contrast, the Myers-Briggs system looks at how an individual prefers to process information and interact with others.
In this article, we will discuss the similarities and differences between each system. We will also examine how they are used in today’s world, why they may be helpful to individuals seeking personal growth or career counseling, and how they can help professionals collaborate more effectively.
Systems Compared: The 9 vs 16 Type
When comparing the Enneagram system vs. the Myers-Briggs system, the Enneagram divides personalities into nine distinct types based on 27 subtypes.
Each of these nine types focuses on motivations and life purpose rather than how individuals prefer to process information or interact with others. While this system is just as effective at understanding individual personalities, it has a much deeper understanding than the MBTI.
On the contrary, the Myers-Briggs system consists of 16 possible personality types based on four opposing personality functions (Introverted, Sensing, Thinking, and Judging). This categorization is known as the MBTI (Myers-Briggs Type Indicator) and has been used in various fields such as psychology and business.
One of the main benefits of using both systems is that they provide insight into different aspects of an individual’s personality.
For example, using both methods can help a person understand their interpersonal relationships better by providing insights into why people behave a certain way or think differently.
Additionally, professionals like counselors, psychologists, or HR personnel often use these systems together to collaborate more effectively when assessing a client’s needs or offering professional advice.
It is important to note that there are also similarities between these two systems despite their different approaches to categorizing personalities. For instance, both emphasize personal growth and development by offering strategies and tips for improving communication skills and understanding yourself better.
Each has strengths and weaknesses that should be considered when looking at which one may best suit your particular needs or situation.
Categories and Structure: 4 Dichotomies vs. 3 Triads
When looking at the differences between the Myers-Briggs and Enneagram systems, it’s essential to consider the categorization and structure of each. The MBTI system is based on four dichotomies, which focus on how an individual perceives the world and interacts with others.
These include Introversion (I) vs. Extraversion (E), Sensing (S) vs. Intuition (N), Thinking (T) vs. Feeling (F), and Judging (J) vs. Perceiving(P). This results in 16 possible combinations that can help individuals better understand their personality traits and how they interact with others.
On the other hand, the Enneagram is divided into three triads which focus on someone’s core emotions and motivations. The three triads are related to what is known as ‘the head,’ ‘the heart,’ and ‘the body’ centers of intelligence, resulting in 9 types total.
Each class has an intense primary emotion associated with it when someone is under stress; Heart types feel Shame, Head types feel Fear, Body types feel Anger, Gut types feel Panic/Anxiety, Social Types feel Rejection/Abandonment, Sexual Types feel Isolation/Despair, Self-Preservation Types feel Deprivation/Loneliness, One-to-One Types feel Despair/Humiliation, and Instinctive Types feel Helplessness/Vulnerability.
This allows for greater insight into what motivates people and helps them relate to one another more effectively.
In addition to the categorization differences between these two systems, there are also structural differences. For example, while both assess individual personalities based on cognitive functions or emotional states, they differ in how they view personality traits.
While MBTI looks at personal characteristics in a broader framework of understanding how different personalities interact with one another, Enneagram looks at personality traits from a holistic perspective focusing on understanding how these traits affect our overall well being.
The Enneagram system offers much more depth than other personality models like the MBTI system by providing insights into our deepest motivations and life purpose. This goes beyond simply understanding our cognitive functions or interactions with others.
By utilizing both methods together, individuals can gain a far richer understanding of their personalities and those around them, which can help in many areas, including communication skills development or career counseling.
What Do Results Tell You? Personality Traits vs Emotions
The Myers-Briggs personality type and Enneagram assessment results can provide valuable insight into individual personalities and how they interact with others.
The MBTI type assessment can help individuals better understand their thinking process and how their behavior and interaction styles might differ from others. Additionally, the MBTI provides practical strategies for improving communication skills that can apply to personal and professional contexts.
On the other hand, the Enneagram system focuses on exploring a person’s underlying emotional motivations behind their thinking and behavior – looking beyond just an individual’s cognitive functions.
This allows individuals to gain a deeper understanding of themselves and those around them, which can be especially helpful in developing better communication skills or working through personal issues.
In addition to providing valuable insights about personality traits versus emotional states, these two systems also provide tips for personal growth and development.
They offer strategies for better understanding oneself, improving communication skills, or resolving conflicts that may arise in interpersonal relationships.
Utilizing both systems can help individuals gain a far richer perspective of themselves and those around them from which they can draw when trying to manage complex relationships or situations.
What Do Tests Highlight? Healthy vs Extremes
The Myers-Briggs personality type and Enneagram systems provide valuable insights into individuals on both a cognitive and emotional level. MBTI test results highlight an individual’s strengths and weaknesses, providing a balanced view of who they are and how they interact with others.
On the other hand, the Enneagram system looks at ‘Levels of Development,’ providing an understanding of the healthy and unhealthy aspects of an individual’s personality type.
The MBTI system outlines how different personalities interact, allowing individuals to understand how their behavior might impact their interactions with others.
This can be especially helpful in developing better communication skills or finding a career path that best suits their personality type. Additionally, utilizing this tool can also help identify potential areas of improvement so that individuals can improve their overall behavior.
The Enneagram system takes a more holistic approach to understanding an individual’s personality traits by looking beyond cognitive functions or emotions.
This assessment focuses on understanding an individual’s deepest motivations and life purpose, which provides valuable insight into why someone might behave in specific ways in different situations.
It also provides strategies for personal growth and development, allowing individuals to gain agency over their own stories by seeing the extremes of themselves as either healthy or unhealthy.
Is Enneagram More Accurate Than MBTI?
It isn’t easy to assess which of the two systems, Myers-Briggs or Enneagram, is more accurate for determining an individual’s personality type. Each method has its benefits and drawbacks that should be considered when determining the most suitable assessment tool for a particular individual.
The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) provides insights into how different individuals interact and how their personalities can be used to understand their behavior and preferences better. This system focuses primarily on cognitive functions and understanding how people process information uniquely.
The results of this test provide a comprehensive overview of an individual’s personality type and potential areas of improvement that they may need to work on. However, the MBTI fails to explain why someone might behave in a certain way, leaving it up to interpretation.
The Enneagram system offers a more holistic approach to understanding an individual’s psychological makeup by delving more profoundly than what is provided by the MBTI alone.
It looks at ‘Levels of Development,’ understanding the healthy and unhealthy aspects of an individual’s personality type and exploring the underlying emotional motivations behind their thinking and behavior.
Furthermore, this system also provides strategies for personal growth and development so that individuals can use this knowledge to make smarter decisions, leading to positive outcomes in their personal and professional lives.
Ultimately, whether or not one system is more accurate depends on the individual being assessed and the information they hope to gain from taking such a test. Those looking for more psychological insight into why someone might act in specific ways could benefit from using the Enneagram system.
In contrast, those looking for a general overview of how different people interact could find value in using the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI).
Can any MBTI have any Enneagram?
The answer to this question is both yes and no. The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator classification system offers insight into how people interact with one another and understand the world around them.
In contrast, the Enneagram system provides a more holistic view of an individual’s overall personality by exploring their underlying motivations and life purpose.
While both methods can be used to gain valuable insight into someone’s behavior, they are not interchangeable – they should be used together to get the most accurate understanding of an individual’s personality type.
When finding correlations between different MBTI types and Enneagram numbers, specific trends can be observed.
Judging (J) types correlate well with being an Enneagram 1, while Feeling (F) types are likely to identify as Type 2.
Thinkers will usually resonate with 3’s, 5’s & 8’s. Feelers may find a better connection with 2’s, 4’s, and 9’S; Judgers typically prefer 1’s or 8’S, and Perceivers are more likely to identify closely with 7’s and 9′.
Extraverted Thinking (Te), with ESTJs and ENTJs being the most evident representatives of an 8 type, and Introverts often gravitate towards Types 4, 5 & 6.
However, while it is possible to identify these correlations between MBTI types and Enneagram numbers, it is essential to note that not everyone fits neatly into these categories.
People can experience aspects of multiple personalities or ways of behaving that don’t fit into either system perfectly – this is why it is so essential for individuals to take both tests in combination to get the most accurate reading of their personality type.
Additionally, everyone develops over time as they gain life experience, which may also impact how they relate to each system – this means that regular assessments will help ensure that individuals have up-to-date insights into how their personalities evolve.
Does Enneagram Affect MBTI?
The answer to this question is yes – the Enneagram system can impact how people score on the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). Although the two systems are not interchangeable, they do have some correlation when understanding an individual’s personality and behavior.
When MBTI and Enneagram types are compatible, this can lead to a lack of internal latitude for other experiences, which can mean that individuals may struggle to express their feelings or think outside their predetermined box accurately.
On the flip side, having conflicting qualities between an individual’s MBTI and Enneagram types can be beneficial in that it makes it easier for them to identify where they are at any given moment and restore control to their True Self to live authentically without external pressures dictating their decisions.
Is 16 personalities the same as Enneagram?
No, the 16 personality system of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) and the Enneagram system are two distinct methods that should not be confused with one another. While both help to explain a person’s behavior and preferences, they serve different purposes in understanding someone’s personality.
The MBTI is based on Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Jung’s typology model, while the Enneagram can be traced back to ancient times, to Pythagoras’ works. The MBTI focuses on how an individual perceives information (Intuition or Sensation) and what criteria they prioritize when making decisions (Thinking or Feeling).
It is something one is born with but can vary from person to person depending on their choices and experiences over time.
Additionally, the MBTI examines an individual’s attitude toward life by measuring four fundamental aspects: Extraversion vs. Introversion, Sensing vs. Intuition, Thinking vs. Feeling, and Judgement vs. Perception.
In contrast, the Enneagram system looks at nine different categories of personality types meant to represent universal human traits such as anger, fear, and pride.
Each type has its own set of characteristics that make up its core identity, and by understanding these traits, people can gain a better insight into their behavior and reactions.
Enneagram also looks at how an individual responds to stress or growth to further understand the motivation behind their decisions.
Conclusion on The Two Personality Systems
To understand the two systems and their respective roles, it is essential first to recognize that they have been developed for different goals and serve other purposes.
While both help assesses an individual’s personality, the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is designed to measure how someone prefers to process information, make decisions and interact with others; At the same time, the Enneagram system looks at emotions and reveals fears, desires, and relationships.
By exploring these two systems side by side, individuals can take advantage of the unique insights offered by each to get a fuller picture of who they are and what drives them – enabling them to make more informed choices when building healthier relationships with themselves and others.